Sabres Have a Zach Benson Problem

Zach Benson is the lone driving force behind the Sabres' attack and the rest of Buffalo's forwards need to pick it up.

By · 4 min read

Zach Benson Buffalo Sabres problem

The Buffalo Sabres have a Zach Benson problem.

No, this is not a statement that reflects poorly on Benson. In fact, it's quite the opposite. Every single Sabres forward is relying on Zach Benson to produce.

We've seen Benson's linemates thrive, whether it's Noah Ostlund and Jack Quinn, or, more recently, Tage Thompson, Peyton Krebs, and Jiri Kulich. Without Benson, these players went cold.

So what gives?

Zach Benson's 2026-27 Season

Zach Benson has been outstanding through the first 21 games of the 2026-27 season. Although he has only managed to put the puck in the net two times, he leads the Sabres with 14 assists. Equally important, he also leads the way in every on-ice metric - Corsi share (60.9%), expected goals share (56.5%), and actual goal share (67.7%).

The offensive impact he has brought to this iteration of the Sabres isn't just the best on Buffalo's roster - it's elite when compared to the rest of the NHL.

Benson ranks in the 99th percentile among forwards at driving offense. Only the Edmonton Oilers duo of Leon Draisaitl and Vasily Podkolzin and New York Rangers captain J.T. Miller rank higher offensively.

His defense is no slouch either. Benson leads the team in plus-minus, regularly adjusted plus-minus (which adjusts for strength of teammates and competition), and is consistently deployed in tough matchups.

If Benson wasn't finishing at nearly seven goals below expected, he'd be leading the team - and perhaps the NHL - in Wins Above Replacement. Even taking into account his putrid 3% scoring rate, Benson ranks fourth among Sabres forwards in WAR.

The Zach Benson Effect

One of the Buffalo forwards who ranks ahead of Benson in WAR is Noah Ostlund. Ostlund burst onto the scene this season in a tenacious, shutdown role as the team's number two center and thrived alongside Benson and Quinn.

The trio has posted a goal share, expected goal share, shot share, and Fenwick (unblocked shots) share all at 60% or higher:

  • Goal share: 67%

  • xG share: 60%

  • SOG share: 63%

  • Fenwick share: 64%

However, since Benson has primarily moved to the top line with Thompson, Ostlund has struggled. Over his past four games, the young Swedish center has posted WARpath grades of D+, D, D-, and D+.

Quinn has gone cold too, scoreless in his last five games. He hasn't posted a "B-" or better game since October.

Moving Benson to play with Thompson was necessary, though, as Tage had been too inconsistent for Buffalo to succeed. Benson and Thompson have complementary skill sets, where Benson's puck-hounding and playmaking set up Thompson's craftiness and elite shot like no other player quite can on the Sabres.

The proof is in the expected goal share, in which Thompson is at a whopping 59% with Benson, and a drastic drop-off of 46% without. He's not the only one, though. Here are the Sabres forwards' xG share with and without Benson:

  • Noah Ostlund, 129 minutes, +0.18

    • With Benson: 60%

    • Without Benson: 42%

  • Jack Quinn, 124 minutes, +0.17

    • With Benson: 59%

    • Without Benson: 42%

  • Tage Thompson, 123 minutes, +0.13

    • With Benson: 59%

    • Without Benson: 46%

  • Peyton Krebs, 88 minutes, +0.03

    • With Benson: 53%

    • Without Benson: 50%

  • Josh Doan, 17 minutes, +0.11

    • With Benson: 58%

    • Without Benson: 47%

  • Jiri Kulich, 12 minutes, -0.08

    • With Benson: 47%

    • Without Benson: 55%

  • Konsta Helenius, 12 minutes, +0.12

    • With Benson: 65%

    • Without Benson: 53%

  • Ryan McLeod, 10 minutes, +0.3

    • With Benson: 77%

    • Without Benson: 47%

  • Josh Norris, 8 minutes, +0.08

    • With Benson: 61%

    • Without Benson: 53%

Only Kulich, in a limited sample, has been more effective without Benson from a scoring-chance perspective. They were on the ice together for Kulich's goal last night against the Philadelphia Flyers, so there's a good chance that changes over time.

What's more concerning is that only three of the nine players who have played with Benson carry an expected goal share above 50% without him on the ice with them. That means that only Kulich, Helenius, and Norris are creating better scoring chances than they are giving up without Benson's help. With Benson's help, seven of the nine are at a whopping 58% or higher!

The bottom line is that the Sabres cannot be this reliant on one player.

Sabres Looking for Answers

So what's the answer to Buffalo's forward woes?

Since triple-shifting Benson isn't feasible, and a significant roster shakeup doesn't seem likely, it's going to have to come internally.

The Sabres have good players, but they can't afford three-quarters of the forward group slumping at once. Norris and Doan are slowly showing signs of improvement. McLeod and Jason Zucker need to come alive. But mostly, Buffalo needs to lean into its fastball from last season.

That fastball, of course, is river hockey.

Tenacious forwards dogging the puck, utilizing the team's mobile defensemen for fluid in-zone puck control, and skating opposing teams into the ground were their identity. The Sabres need to find that edge again and carry that swagger for the rest of the season.

Zach Benson does it every game. It's time the rest of the Buffalo Sabres do it too.

Jason Moser@PuckLuckJay

Jason Moser is the founder of WARpath Buffalo and PuckLuck. He built the models and tools behind both, doubling as a data scientist and engineer. A Buffalo native, he's covered the Sabres for nearly a decade between WARpath, Buffalo Hockey Now, and SBNation.

More from Jason
Get it in your inboxSabres coverage and analytics. Free, no ads, unsubscribe in one click.

More coverage · See the ratings